Sole proprietorship or GmbH: quick comparison
Sole proprietorship or GmbH? In Geneva and the rest of French-speaking Switzerland, the GmbH is called a Sàrl (GmbH, limited liability company), and the sole proprietorship (raison individuelle) keeps its French name in official documents. This page uses “Sàrl” from here on.
| Criterion | Sole proprietorship | Sàrl |
|---|---|---|
| Legal personality | No, tied to the owner | Yes, separate company |
| Minimum capital | None | CHF 20,000, fully paid up |
| Liability | Personal and unlimited | In principle limited to the company’s assets |
| Notary | Not required | Notarial deed mandatory |
| Commercial register (Registre du commerce) | Mandatory from CHF 100,000 in turnover | Mandatory, and the company comes into existence on registration |
| Bookkeeping | Simplified below CHF 500,000 in turnover | Full bookkeeping |
This table sets out general rules. It is not enough to decide without looking at the business, the partners, the risks and the tax position.
Choosing a sole proprietorship
A sole proprietorship can suit someone starting out alone, without share capital, with a simple service business. It is lighter to set up and, legally, it is managed directly by its owner.
The main trade-off is personal liability. The business’s debts can reach your private assets. The legal separation between the business and the person is also less clear.
Choosing a Sàrl
A Sàrl can suit you when you need to separate the business more clearly from yourself, bring in partners or formalise governance. It has its own legal personality and keeps full accounts.
Setting one up requires CHF 20,000 of share capital, a notary and registration in the commercial register. The capital stays in the company after incorporation, subject to the applicable rules. It should not be confused with the cost of the formation package.
Compare the tax position with care
A sole proprietorship and a Sàrl are not taxed the same way. With a sole proprietorship, the business result is attributed to the person. A Sàrl is taxed as a legal entity, and the income received by the partner or managing director follows its own rules.
The comparison depends on the profit, the salary, pension provision, your family situation and many other factors. A generic claim that one form is always better for tax purposes would be misleading.
Think about the next two years
Before you choose, ask yourself:
- will you work alone or with partners;
- what financial risk the business carries;
- do you need capital or investors;
- do you plan to hire;
- do your clients expect a company structure;
- do you want to sell or pass on the business;
- can you absorb the extra administration of a Sàrl.
The meeting included in the Apex packages is used to organise this comparison before the formalities begin. Official filings with the Geneva authorities remain in French, but we can discuss your file in English.